I am NOT an affiliate for 6060eyes, I just love their safety doll eyes and noses. My favorite safety doll eyes are the handpainted Christmas wreaths that I used on my Crochet Christmas Elves:
From their web site:
“We specialize in high quality factory stock and hand-painted safety eyes, superior selection, fast shipping, and a great customer experience. 6060eyes is the sister site to 6060eyes.etsy.com, a top Etsy seller for over 10 years. Your hand-painted eyes are painted to order and shipped fast.
Located in the USA, our wide selection of stock safety eyes in round, oval, cat, owl and frog styles are perfect for amigurumi, stuffed toys, teddy bears, plush toys, fishing lures, carvings, puppets and more.
Another place that I love to purchase safety doll eyes and noses is Glass eyes online.com
If you can’t find something you are looking for from those two sites, you may also like Eyes & Supplies.com